Made to order eyes have a 7-10 business day processing time!
It's that time again - Halloween eyes are here! Add character and individuality to your plushie or stuffed animal creation with a unique high-quality pair of safety eyes! This collection of specialty designs from glow in the dark bats to shimmery seasonal glitter is available for a limited time in 25mm and 30mm sinker style eyes. Designed by me and handcrafted to order, you can choose your pupil size and color. This listing is for one pair (2 eyes total) of handcrafted safety eyes designed by me with appropriate backings for each eye. These specialty eyes are handmade to order in a cat-friendly, smoke-free home in Massachusetts, and they will be shipped 1-2 weeks from purchase.
Please note that due to the handmade nature of this product, eyes may vary slightly in composition and coloring from photos. Make sure you look through all the photos as many of these eyes are colorshift and will change color in different lighting situations (sunlight vs indoor, angles, etc.)
If you don't see the eye options you want, please contact me - custom eyes are available!
Haunted Collection:
Nightmares: Three spooky ghosts against a pearlescent grey sky.
Bat Cave: Glow in the dark bats with a glittery dark purple background with flecks of gold. (Make sure you charge them in the sun!)
Spiderweb: Spiderwebs against a dark green glittery background with hints of purple.
Tombstone: A tombstone and black bats against a glittery neon green glow in the dark background.
Important information:
Sinker eyes: These eyes are designed to sit flush with your plush and require a safety eye tool or jig to install properly, especially when working with plush yarn. Many sellers on Etsy sell these tools. Attempting to install these eyes without one may result in damage to the eye.
*WARNING: Due to potential choking hazard, safety eyes are not recommended for children under 3.*
🧶Custom orders take 1-2 weeks depending on how many orders are pending. They will be shipped out next business day as soon as they are complete! Unfortunately we cannot offer returns or refunds on plushies that have been custom made for you.
🧶Sizes of plushies are detailed in each item description. For custom plushies, size may vary slightly - crochet is not an exact science and size can differ slightly depending on yarn type and tension.
🧶Yes! I can make any ready-to-ship plushie as a custom order. Message me or click the 'Request Custom Order' button above to submit your request. I'm open to customs of other plushies as well! Turnaround time for custom orders is 2-3 weeks and does not include shipping time.
Safety eyes are a potential choking hazard for children under 3 due to being small pieces. Although they are secured inside the plushie, my items are not tested and therefore not sold as children's toys. I do offer an embroidered eye option for custom plushies.
Yes! Custom safety eye orders are open. Click the 'Request Custom Order' button to submit your request. I offer tons of different size and pupil options and customization can include glow in the dark, sparkle, opal, splatter, galaxy, chameleon and specialty designs! Custom eyes take up to 2 weeks to handcraft before shipment.
Nov 28, 2025
Beautifully painted safety eyes easy to put on and just gorgeous
Aug 27, 2025
Will definitely come in handy for the plush I want to work with
Dec 9, 2024
I love these eyes so much! I can't wait to put them on something for a friend
Dec 9, 2024
These are so precious I can't wait to use them
Oct 15, 2024
These eyes are so perfect!! Amazing color